Buyers are Liars. Wait, What?

Want to do an interesting online search? Fire up your favorite browser and go looking for “Buyers are Liars.”

It’s a common phrase in several industries—car sales and real estate, for example. In each of those industries, you can find two related-but-different versions of that phrase.

In version one, it is usually spoken by a resentful salesperson, as in, “Can you believe that guy? He told me he would be right back within the hour, but, well, you know—they walk out the door, they’re gone. Buyers are liars.”

In version two, a more seasoned seller, often in conversation with a young trainee, speaks it. It goes, “If they say they want a cul de sac, brick construction, east-facing kitchen—don’t believe it. Maybe one of those is key—the others they’ll compromise on, because you know, buyers are liars. You have to find out what they really want, they don’t know themselves. They don’t mean to lie; that’s just how they think.”

Both views are right. And both are reflections of businesses in which the seller holds a lot of power by virtue of expertise and a potentially menacing and arcane sales process. Not surprisingly, buyers respond with their own attempt to control the situation—withholding or otherwise manipulating the truth.

This is precisely the dynamic I’ve observed over the years in watching clients buy professional services. Clients have not been to buyers’ school. They don’t know what to ask, but are afraid of being flim-flammed. So they resort to what feels low-risk—asking the seller to recite their qualifications and testimonials.

The weaker salespeople take the potential client at face value, and actually believe they want to hear the selling firm’s resumes and past client history. Then follows the sleep-inducing recitation and powerpoint avalanche.

Do client buyers lie? Yes, and mainly it’s the services firms’ fault. The trick is to get to that place of mutual admission that there’s something each can bring to the party.

What about a very different industry?

A University of Texas study explores the “buyers are liars” theme in the market for entrepreneurial firms, often by private equity buyers. As the study’s author, Melissa Graebner, puts it:

… buyers were not only less trusting than sellers, they were more likely to be dishonest. Beyond price bluffing, several buyers engaged in what Graebner calls "material deception" with regard to their plans for post-integration "layoffs, changes in strategic direction or diminished roles for senior managers."

Sellers—generally smaller firms owned by the person who created them—appeared far more trusting of suitors. Little surprise, perhaps, given the passionate, conquering nature of entrepreneurs: "Me big geek," one seller told Graebner. "I’m a technologist. I want to build something that I want everyone to use. I want my ego boost! I’m not here for a quick buck, I’m here to do my big thing."

Another reason for the trust gap between buyers and sellers, notes Graebner, is the perceived transfer of power. "In the course of an acquisition, sellers lose power while buyers gain power," she says. "Given their prospects of heightened power, buyers viewed a seller’s trustworthiness as nonessential."

In car and real estate sales, I would say the seller has most of the power, and customers lie out of fear, recognizing that fact.

In professional services, it is the clients/buyers who often hold more power, yet don’t know it; so they also act from fear—with a result that is often harmful to both parties. The advertising industry may be an extreme example lately.

In Graebner’s study, I think the buyer has the most power again; but here the ego weakness is on the part of the seller, not the buyer. And it’s not fear that’s afoot, it’s a desire for ego stroking.

Sellers want to believe they can trust the buyer. And so many buyers, who truly do have the power, choose to lie.

Are buyers liars? Yes, but as a current movie says: it’s complicated.

3 replies
  1. JR Griggs
    JR Griggs says:

    Great post!

    As a former car salesman I can definitely attest to the "buyers are liars". The "I’ll be back" lie is the most common, but also the "well the other dealer was selling me one for $10,000 less" lol. But as a car salesman we were able to figure our about 90% of the lies. Especially when we can view the other dealer’s inventory and see they don’t even have the same vehicle. I could write a book with the stories from car sales.

    But as a business consultant I have also seen my fair share of lies and in this case it hurts the client far more than a car buyer. Many times the strategies I will try to impliment for the business will fail becuase the client told me something that was not true. Maybe they feel embarrassed to tell the truth? Or they did not know the truth?

     

    Hopefully with the way social media is changing the game, this will allow better trust between buyer and seller.

    Reply
  2. barbara garabedian
    barbara garabedian says:

    I’ve been on both sides within professional services and both sides tend to "lie"… just a tad. I prefer the term, stretch the truth. In retrospect, I believe the "buyers" have the edge here in regard to stretching. I agree, most of the "stretching" on both sides does result from a of lack of trust – at some level.  Many moons ago, consultant’s were considered snake oil salesmen, not professionals…and frankly, there was some element of truth to it. So it was buyer beware and never trust them at their word – they lie! Time moves on…consulting is now a respected profession but buyers are still cautious, disbelieving and generally don’t take the consultant’s (seller) at their word. 

    As a "buyer", I created a list of some of the more common lies (stretches of the truth ) from sellers. My three favorites included, "trust me"; "that’s a fixed cost w/ all charges included" and, of course, everyone’s favorite, "yes, of course we will deliver on schedule and on budget".

    As a "seller", I was delighted for buyers to say that they were just investigating options or looking for information, as oppose to a big "song & dance". Then I was able to provide them w/what they wanted or needed. It was productive for both sides. Somehow buyers don’t generally believe (or trust) sellers to provide them w/what they want & need, if they think the seller believes a sale isn’t imminent or large enough. They won’t be taken seriously. So they "lie’. 

     

    The most hurtful buyer "lie", in my experience, was when they couldn’t tell me the real reason why I wasn’t selected to do the work (granted it was probably done out of some level of empathy, compassion, fear or cowardice). I wanted & needed the truth versus some contrived story. As painful as it might have been, I could have "learned" something and then considered those reasons in my next go around. Somehow buyers don’t trust sellers enough to hear the truth, "…your solution is fine, my mgr just doesn’t like you, XYZ has a much better solution, we need a Scion,you’re offering a Mercedes, etc". They are afraid of the potential confrontation.

     

    In today’s world there is nothing wrong w/Buyer Beware, it is prudent behavior. How unfortunate though that buyers and sellers can’t have a working relationship where it is understood that each can and will tell the other the truth, AND believe that each is professional enough to act accordingly.  

    Reply

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. […] “Business is going well for me at the moment but I’ll definitely keep you in mind in the future!” Lies, damn lies! […]

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.