Consultants’ News and the Institute of Management Consultants USA report on a survey about how much clients trust consultants.
Say CN and IMC:
Survey results…reveal that the consulting profession is viewed as trustworthy. When respondents were asked to rank a list of 10 representative professions from most trustworthy to least trustworthy, they ranked consulting as the 5th most trustworthy profession, behind nurses, doctors, teachers and accountants. Rounding out the list of professions were sales representatives, corporate executives, attorneys, journalists and politicians.
Hmmm. If you’re ranked fifth out of ten, you’re “viewed as trustworthy.” Presumably, sixth place gets you “untrustworthy.” There but for grace of sales representatives and journalists…
Want to know why nurses consistently rank #1 on these kinds of lists? Meet the President of the American Nursing Association. She could sell me a used car. Why? Because she virtually bleeds low self-orientation. You’d have a hard time finding less than six degrees of separation between her and anyone with a selfish bone in their body.
Similar results come from an Australian survey of trusted professions done annually since 1970. Tops are nurses, pharmacists and doctors; the bottom four—numbers 26 – 29—are various salespersons. Just above them, at 24 and 25 (out of 29) are TV reporters and newspaper journalists.
In Australia, unlike the CN poll, politicians barely outrank journalists. Pretty scary, for both countries, if you ask me.
In neighboring New Zealand, the top three trusted professions are fire fighters, ambulance officers, and—you guessed it—nurses. The bottom three (of 30) are psychics, car salesmen, and politicians. Wow—below psychics.
Edelman’s Trust Barometer , in 2006, reported:
Global opinion leaders say their most credible source of information about a company is now “a person like me,” which has risen dramatically to surpass doctors and academic experts for the first time, according to the seventh annual Edelman Trust Barometer, a survey of nearly 2,000 opinion leaders in 11 countries. In the U.S., trust in “a person like me” increased from 20% in 2003 to 68% today. Opinion leaders also consider rank-and-file employees more credible spokespersons than corporate CEOs (42% vs. 28% in the U.S.).
In 2004, the Public Broadcasting System was “the most trusted institution on a list of nationally known organizations in the country…” Hey, I’m a fan too. But shouldn’t the most trusted institution tell us who was second, how many there were, and who was in last place? Come on PBS, dish a little—you’ve got your credibility to defend here!
In India, media is the most trusted institution. In the Ukraine—at least in 2004—it’s the church.
While polling about trust in Serbia, there were problems:
"Concerning trust in Milosevic", Bogosavljevic continues, "it is notable that many people simply didn’t want to answer questions about him. For years ordinary people were taught that Milosevic was the greatest, and now they are told that they are supposed to be against him. Many of them simply can’t do this, so their response is simply to say ‘I don’t know’ or refuse to answer."
What’s it all mean?
Sometimes trust stays the same for a long time—part of our trust for nurses is that we’ve always trusted nurses. When trust changes rapidly, it can be disorienting to us.
There are few surprises in surveys—they almost always “make sense” when we hear results.
Most of all, trust touches our lives broadly—people, professions, and institutions are only a handful of arenas in which trust plays out in our lives. It’s neither simple, nor one-dimensional. And it’s all very human.
I think Robert Cialdini would have predicted the "person like me" result!
For anyone who doesn’t know Mike’s reference here, Robert Cialdini is an authority on influence–how it is that people come to be influenced by others. His book is a must-read for anyone seeking to do so–salespeople, consultants, lawyers, etc.
Check out Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion. It’s a great read.
Thanks for the tip, Mike. And check out Mike’s own blog for more solid insights.
Thanks for joining us in the Carnival of Australia. This was a most excellent post to include. My husband is an accountant and a business consultant so I rubbed the results in.
We hope to see you again next fortnight.
The Carnival of Principled Government is up. Thanks for your entry!