The Ugly Truth Behind Goldman Director’s Resignation
A few hours ago, the New York Times published a blistering Op Ed by Greg Smith, a Goldman Sachs director, titled Why I Am Leaving Goldman Sachs. It is getting remarkable coverage in the twittersphere, blogosphere and conventional press.
And no wonder! It is a scathing indictment by a privileged insider of one of the great Wall Street firms. It’s Matt Taibbi’s Vampire Squid story all over again – but this time from the Inner Circle.
I’m going to let everyone else revel in the spectacle of moral outrage, and focus on one statement Mr. Smith makes:
If clients don’t trust you they will eventually stop doing business with you. It doesn’t matter how smart you are.
This is true: but occasionally clients will need a little help from their friends.
Trust or Money?
The public dialogue about trust in business is polarized. One side says, “Trustworthy behavior ultimately pays off.” The other side says, “Get real, only suckers believe that.”
I’m a believer in free markets. I also believe free markets are relatively rare. Here’s how trust plays out in them.
The market for trust at the most basic level – interpersonal relationships – is very free. If you behave in an untrustworthy manner, you will lose the trust of others, quickly and surely. If you betray a co-worker or a boss, you’ll get your come-uppance quickly. Ditto for one-on-one retail businesses.
It is also at that level – the deeply personal – that trust is strongest. The difficulty always comes in scaling trust.
The easiest form of social trust is tribal, clan-based. Think of the Mafia, think Chinese family culture, think sports fans. The way to operate a really successful clan is through culture. Read Francis Fukuyama on national cultures of trust.
Now read Epicurean Dealmaker on Goldman Sachs’ culture, The Fish Stinks from the Head, written three years ago. This movie has been playing for some time now.
When corporations achieve great internal trust through strong culture, they can accomplish great things. They can also accomplish terrible things.
The market for trust at the corporate level is far, far from a free market. The power of tribal trust alone is enough to crush dissenting individuals. Whistle-blowers rarely fare well; and the stronger the culture, the worse they are treated.
We hear too often the debate about whether trust is profitable or not. In the long run, across enough organizations, the answer is yes. (See Trust Across America for some data to this effect).
The question is: is there a linkage in the shorter term, in fewer interactions? If Greg Smith is right that customers eventually leave untrustworthy companies – how come it takes them so long?
The Wheels of Justice Grind Exceeding Slow
There is no iron-clad “law” of social justice that says high trust will yield high returns, or that good will be returned for good, etc. Despite the best efforts of trust proponents and new-order-capitalism theorists, the trustworthy behavior of one individual or one company is not guaranteed to be rewarded in this lifetime, this market, this quarter.
Worse yet, downright villainous bad behavior can be rewarded very, very handsomely. Greg Smith quit Goldman today after 12 years; but those 12 years have been astronomically profitable for Goldman. Markets these days are far from free and trust doesn’t pay off quickly.
So let’s not be naïve about the inherent power of trust to vanquish all evil.
The challenge for all of us is to get above tribal trust and climb to a higher level of societal trust.
Can the GOP stop its circular firing squad? Can the US Congress ever serve its broader constituency? Can organizations like Goldman re-learn how to transfer internal trust to external clients? Can salespeople learn to trust, and entrust, their customers? Can the Chamber of Commerce stop fighting regulators?
Goldman can’t be relied on to fix itself. It has failed to do so. The question is not how evil they are or how many more public resignations it will take. It is how long will society wait for corrections to happen?
The Invisible Hand is not all-seeing when it comes to trust. In fact, it can be downright blind. Occasionally, clients need a little help.
What is To Be Done?
You can find your own battle in this framing of the war. Ask yourself: whom do you trust? Who’s your clan? Who do you throw in with?
Then ask yourself: whom am I fighting? Who is the enemy? Who don’t I trust? And challenge yourself to take it to another level.
Don’t be a voyeur watching the Goldman saga turned into TMZ gossip television. Use it. Do something about it. Up the stakes.
Trust one-on-one is easy. Even tribes and corporate culture aren’t all that hard. The challenge is to remember that we no longer live in a tribal world.
The Ugly Truth in the Goldman story is that it’s not self-correcting. This is not a Greek tragedy with the gods pulling the strings. It’s not even a Hollywood comedy, with script-writers pulling us to a natural resolution.
Social trust is a choice, not an inevitable law of nature. And this is not a dress rehearsal.